4 Simple Ways To Destroy Your Own Brand In One Day

Steve Fogg —  October 30, 2011 — 13 Comments

Qantas is one of Australia’s most prestigious brands. It is the national airline. It has had an extremely high-profile and enjoys the reputation of being one of the safest airlines in the world (It also trades off this fact). Aussies have had a national love affair with Qantas over the years. Its logo is also one of Australia’s national symbols and many consider part of their national identity.

Today Alan Joyce and the executive management of Qantas just ended that love affair and mauled the airline’s brand equity and it’s reputation in one day.

While there is a clear industrial relations strategy in play here from Qantas. Here are some reasons why the management have made the wrong move from a public relations, reputation management and marketing perspective:

1. People can see through spin and cynical timing (It’s a self-inflicted PR disaster of epic proportions)

Qantas claim that they only met on Saturday morning to ground the airline which according to politicians and Qantas pilots association wouldn’t be possible. The Qantas pilots representative claimed that Qantas has been booking out hotel rooms for some time in preparation for this. To make announce their decision to ground the airline only a day after their annual general meeting where Mr Joyce received a significant pay rise sends a terrible message to the Australian public. It smacks of cool calculated timing to avoid any push-back from institutional investors. Australians will see straight through this and Qantas are immediately with their backs to the wall in the PR battle with the unions. Where once there was public ambivalence at the union claim, the sentiment has changed. The majority of public sentiment is now with the unions. That is a PR disaster.

2. Good news travels fast, bad news travels at the speed of light (It’s a word of mouth disaster)

It is being reported that domestic 68,000 passengers are affected every day by the grounding and over 13,000 international travellers. That is 81,000 people who now that are either trying to re-book their flight with another airline or some of whom are stuck somewhere around the world in a hotel room waiting for another flight or a rescheduled Qantas flight. I’ve written about the power of word of mouth before Word of mouth marketing can work for you but it can also work against you if the sentiment is negative. Just imagine the 81,000 people telling their closest nearest and dearest friends (lets say that is 4 people each), that would be over a quarter of a million people who would have been told about their negative experience every single day.

There was also a social media meltdown on Twitter yesterday. Qantas accounted for 0.64% of global Twitter traffic yesterday which is massive. Sentiment towards the company was 72% negative and 28% positive.

Here is one sarcastic play on the Qantas advertising jingle I saw on Facebook this morning:

“I’ve been to airports that never close down,
From New York to Rio and old London town,”

I wonder if Qantas social media team is measuring this ROI?

Alan Joyce’s personal branding is also going to take a hit if he doesn’t resolve this quickly by making even more money for the Qantas shareholders and restore confidence from key stakeholders including government. Here is what could be at stake if Mr Joyce fails in his Industrial Relations efforts. Who would employ a CEO that would take down their own brand?

3. It takes years to build your reputation and a moment to lose it.

As I wrote in the introduction to this post the Australian public has had a love affair with the Qantas over the decades. The airlines brand equity is very high. There is a strong loyalty to the brand. There is also a deep emotional connection with the brand. Australians also have a high sense of ownership of the brand, even if they don’t own shares, they consider it ‘one of us’. These are precious attributes that takes years to develop. The Qantas executive team has just lost years of brand equity in one day.

4. Give your struggling competition a free kick

Qantas needs to get ready to lose market share. This is the real damage. Lost business. This could be Alan Joyce’s Crocodile Dundee moment: “That’s not how you lose market share. THIS is how you lose market share!” The other airlines must be licking their lips in anticipation of increased revenue. Virgin has had a tough time of late with Jetstar taking a lot of their market share. If I were the marketing team of Virgin I would ensure that every traveller would receive something special over the next week to win the hearts of the frustrated travellers. Such an easy marketing win.

Qantas may win the battle but they may lose the war.

This is a risky strategy (some would say gutsy) Qantas are undertaking. They are fighting an industrial relations battle with different unions who are attacking them one by one. Death by a thousand cuts. Qantas are looking to force the Federal Government hand to stop all industrial action in one fell swoop (which the government can do). Qantas may win the IR battle but may lose it’s brand equity, public relations and reputation management battle in the process. More importantly Qantas will also lose the public’s loyalty and a massive slice of the market share in the process.

Are you a Qantas customer? What do you think about what they have done? Comment below.

If you liked this post, please say thanks by sharing it:

Related posts:

  1. Qantas Makes A Complete Hash Of Social Media Tweet Campaign
  2. The Ugly Truth About Marketing
  3. 6 Simple Ways To Build Your Volunteer Communications Team
  4. Branding Basics – What Is A Brand?

13 responses to 4 Simple Ways To Destroy Your Own Brand In One Day

  1. Excellent post, Steve. As a former journo and PR consultant, I cannot believe that someone did not think through the ramifications of this move.

    • The scarey think Nikki is I think Qantas know exactly what they are doing. And none of us know the big picture, even the unions of govt.

      I personally think they are in the early phases of breaking the company up into smaller business units to make it more adaptive to the rapidly changing aviation climate.

  2. I understand the giant doing something desperate to stop the death by a thousand cuts. Qantas travellers have had their travel plans endangered time and time again by the unions, so I imagine they would understand why Qantas would have to pull the pin like this one. The unions have been sapping the public’s loyalty and Qantas’ market share for years. It’s time for the giant to roar.

  3. I too understand all the ramifications & believe me, I also understand the ramifications to my own business. (which has suffered enough in the last two years, being relatively reliant on the tourist trade & airplanes that deliver!)
    But, all that aside, I am inclined to agree w Murray’s comments. Your own anolagy of “death by a thousand cuts” was so true. At sometime, in any fight, a line must be drawn. IR was sapping the life force of our own “national icon” which has now said “enough”. There will be divisions in opinions…. Those who agree, who may be business owners or upper management types & people from all walks of life who have already been disadvantaged in some way, in some part of their life, by union action.
    Then there will be those that disagree, in particular, those who’s little lives have been traumatized by missing a flight, those who’se big lives have been unable to complete their goals (ie: Doctors traveling to patients) & those who earn their pay rises & their time off due to industrial action.
    So, love or hate the decision made by Quantas, I do understand it in principle.

    • Thanks for comment Jem, it seems there are two sides of consumers in this debate. One that doesn’t like what the unions are doing and the other that doesn’t like what the airline has done to the people that are travelling. I don’t think many think about why Qantas don’t care about trashing their own brand. Perhaps they know it won’t b around in a few years?

  4. it may be that Allan Joyce is the man of steel who made the toughest business decision in aviation history, and that as a result qantas business customers give him huge respect and the brand strengthens. I bought a ticket yesterday becasue I am now confident it will fly on time without delay!

  5. I’m behind Qantas on this one. The unions were going to destroy Qantas (leaving them with no brand to do anything with). Every week they were losing $15million. No one was booking on Qantas anymore because they had no guarantee a flight with Qantas would get them there.

    PR isn’t an end in itself – it’s about managing the needs of the company and the direction it needs to take. I think Qantas’ response (and very generous compensation, including to all Frequent Flyers) is a good response, and it won’t take long for Qantas to recover.

    • This has been a really interesting post for me. Alot of professional people like us who are in the ‘business’ are more focused about the IR or PR strategy rather than the customers. I get your point, but most ordinary customers don’t give a rats about what Qantas protects itself. They just want reliability and a airline that does what it says it will do.

  6. Though from many perspectives Qantas actions can be seen as not favourable, but if you are looking at teh long run where an organisation is slowly eatne form inside through the unions and trade and is despite so many limitations expected to still deliver, yet walk away with all blame its HIGH time in teh global industry to take actions and set by example.

    Look at PIA, an airline that is teh national flag carrier fo Pakistan,has been a driving force behind developing many otehr airlines {60 approx} and became a dumping ground for political governmnets as the most preffered employment thrown to teh electorate, thats latter through unions and asosciations hijacked any and all policy or change measure.

    Its time the unions are monitored and regulate dto remian within teh role of protecting rights and not hijacking the corporate itself in its entirety.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. 3 Ice Cool Tips To Stop Your Brand From A Digital Melt-Down | Steve Fogg: Clear & Simple - November 15, 2011

    [...] have a hard enough time competing for attention on the shelf but you are doing a really good job at destroying your brand’s reputation all by [...]

  2. Qantas Makes A Complete Hash Of Social Media Tweet Campaign | Steve Fogg: Clear & Simple - November 22, 2011

    [...] when I thought things couldn’t get any worse for Qantas. Their brand took a further nose dive today (excuse the pun). They had a go at relaunching their [...]

  3. The Ugly Truth About Marketing | Steve Fogg: Clear & Simple - February 29, 2012

    [...] that they are a retail business with customers. They made a bad call by treat their customers like pawns so they can win their industrial relations dispute with their [...]

  4. How To Avoid Sucking At Social Media | Steve Fogg: Clear & Simple - March 15, 2012

    [...] towards you. Qantas unfortunately didn’t do that and ran a campaign just after their nearly destroyed their brand in a single day by making a complete hash of a social media campaign. Their social media team or management [...]

Leave a Reply


Text formatting is available via select HTML. <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>